How to Order a Cake from Sam’s Club

Sam’s Club offers delicious and affordable cakes, cupcakes, cookie cakes, or a combination! These cakes are offered in many different sizes, designs, and colors. Use this guide to browse designs and pick your favorite!

You guys, we went to Sam’s Club a few days ago for the first time in YEARS! We met my mom and sister there. She was looking for wedding cakes. Yes, wedding cakes from Sam’s Club! We were pleasantly surprised at the store. You know we LOVE Costco but can’t get over the prices and variety of Sam’s Club cakes. If you are a Costco member you can read about Costco cakes here but we’ve found that Sam’s Club has a lot more variety in the sizes and designs!

Need a party tray to go with your cake? Sam’s Club has you covered with many to choose from like the sundried tomato & buffalo chicken wraps combo tray, sliced meat & cheese tray, fruit & cheese tray, and/or chicken salad croissant sandwiches. Learn more about Sam’s Club party trays here.

Our local Sam’s Club requires you to call in your order or drop off the order form in person. See the pictures below the order forms for more detail on what options are available.

Trying to throw a party on a budget?

>>> How to Throw a Party for less than $48 by Shopping at Sam’s Club

Please note that this post is not associated with Sam’s Club. Prices, selection, availability, and the process to order may vary depending on location so call your local store to be sure your location has the same procedure.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. How do I order a cake?
   • Each location will be different. I suggest finding the phone number for your local store to double check their process. For our local store, you can phone in orders or drop them off at the bakery.
2. How much does it cost?
   • It depends on the size of the cake – see information below.
3. How many does the cake feed?
   • It depends on the size of the cake – see information below.
4. How big is the cake?
   • It depends on the size of the cake – see information below.
5. What are my icing and filling options?
   • See the information below
6. What designs are available?
   • See the images below
7. Can they do a custom design?
   • I do not think that Sam’s Club will do custom designs. However, you can order a plain cake and add your own designs.
8. How long in advance do you have to order?
   • They suggest at least 24 hours but they do have cakes available (not personalized) for purchase all the time at our local Sam’s Club near the bakery. Some cakes (such as the ones with monogram letters) have to be placed 5-7 days in advance.

Below is the form for the special cakes and cupcakes. Sam’s Club has so many options! They offer the following options:

• 10″ round cake (serves 12-16)
• 1/2 sheet cake (serves 36-48)
• full sheet cake (serves 72-96)
• cupcakes (30 count)
• 1/2 sheet cake cupcake combo (serves 64-74)
• cupcake cake (serves 30)
• cookie cake (serves 36-48)
• 5″ cake/10 cupcakes (serves 14-16)

HUGE UPDATE! We made a video for you! This is what the cake design book and stand look like currently (December 2018) at our local Sam’s Club. Watch below. If you see a design you like you can pause the video to view longer.

Click here to view the form as a PDF

Below is the form for the tiered cakes (usually ones that you would see at weddings or more formal events).

Click here to view the form as a PDF

Below is an example of icing colors but keep in mind that these colors look very different on a computer. It is best to visit your local store to determine what icing color you want on your cake.

I’ve also included pictures of a few of the designs available at our local Sam’s Club in Gainesville, GA. They have an entire book of designs that you can flip through in the store!